Newsletter | Our Ultraprocessed World
If you’ve been reading us for a while, you know our schtick: the products and services of everyday life form an environment – we call it the “product environment” – that makes it hard for people to be healthy. Instead of asking people to try harder to overcome this environment, we need to change the environment so that it facilitates better health. So you can imagine our delight in seeing a new essay from psychologist Angelea Duckworth in the New York Times that eloquently articulates this same argument.
In These Inventions Were Built to Trick Us, Duckworth starts with an anecdote about how the biologist Niko Timbergen showed how animals can be fooled by cues that activate their instincts that have been shaped by evolution. Cut to today, where Duckworth argues, skilled product designers are doing the same thing – playing on our evolutionary instincts to get us to consume products that are bad for us. Duckworth cites several of our favorites:
ultraprocessed foods, with their exquisite balance of sugar, salt and fat, of course;
social media, with its “digital Doritos” of short videos, and its links to social comparison and looksmaxxing;
online gambling, which has brought the less accessible casino format to a 24/7 experience at our fingertips; and
AI, which she labels “the most powerful ultraprocessing technology of all.”
We are living, Duckworth argues, in an “ultraprocessed world.” Companies are using the playbook from ultraprocessed foods – creating the craveable, irresistible experiences that overwhelm our knowledge that they aren’t good for us in the long run. The modern world, she sums up with great understatement, doesn’t “bring out our best” – by design.
Duckworth’s primary solution is for us, as individuals, to change our microenvironments. Drawing from her new book, Situated: Find the People and Places that Bring Out Your Best, Duckworth offers a series of hacks, such as keeping your phone out of your bedroom at night, not putting junk food in your pantry, using app blockers like One Sec that force you to pause and be intentional before opening time sucking apps (see also This App Brutally Shames You by Tracking How Many Hours You’ve Lost to Scrolling) and taking GLP-1s to blunt our desires for hyperpalatable food (and maybe for a whole lot of other unhealthy habits). The apps blockers and the GLP-1s are prime examples of what we might call “compensating technologies,” or technologies that have been created to mitigate the harms that have resulted from mainstream technological innovations. Duckworth’s central argument in Situated is that success comes not just from talent, hard work and perseverance, but also from one’s situation and using one’s agency to craft a situation that supports one’s goals.
However, Duckworth acknowledges, there are limits to what individuals can accomplish fighting the ultraprocessed world with our own agency. This acknowledgement is significant coming from Duckworth, who’s famous for her 2016 bestseller, Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance. Even such a champion of summoning one’s own internal resources recognizes that we are creating a world which we can no longer expect people to overcome. Some amount of collective action is needed to change the broader, shared environment that affects each of our individual lives. In particular, Duckworth suggests soda taxes, cellphone bans in schools, regulation of frontier AI models and prohibition of certain product features, such as attention-capturing social media algorithms and in-game microbets on sports gambling platforms.
These last two suggestions point to a developing school of thought – focusing on the particular features and product designs that bring about harmful behavior rather than restricting access to the broader products or services. We’re seeing interesting work in this vein come out of the European Union. In Duolingo, Strava, and Ticketmaster Are All Caught Up in EU’s New Digital Fairness Rules, WIRED’s Isabella Ward discusses the EU’s new rules that go after “dark patterns” such as falsely claiming that a product is running low or making a service hard to cancel. They also require influencers to (gasp!) disclose when they’re being paid to promote a product and, perhaps most importantly, require apps and services to let users turn off addictive design features such as autoplay on videos and streaks. Through these rules, the EU is drawing a distinction between the inherent appeal of a product or services and the manipulative tricks the companies are using to turbocharge that appeal. A similar approach was taken in last summer’s settlement of lawsuits against Meta, in which the company agreed to a number of design changes to Facebook and Instagram, such as the ability to turn off algorithmic feeds, suppressing like counts and blocking extreme makeup and cosmetic surgery filters.
We might live in an ultraprocessed world, but we might also be at an inflection point. We have seen how the backlash against data centers (which can easily be seen as a proxy for AI more broadly or even Silicon Valley more broadly) has turned into a potent political force. Regulators and attorneys general are demanding changes. These reactions in the past have often been focused on individual industries, targeting food manufacturers, or social media companies. But increasingly, essays like Angela Duckworth’s are connecting the dots across these industries and seeing the deeper patterns. The next challenge is to develop remedies that strike not just at the specific malignant practices of individual companies or industries, but also at the policy conditions that enable and encourage those practices.
Read the full newsletter.